Human Trafficking and Migrant Smuggling: Elements, Sanctions, Supreme Court Decisions, and Legal Solutions

Entrance

Migration is increasing due to globalization and wars. This situation has led to the spread of serious crimes such as human trafficking and migrant smuggling. The Turkish Penal Code (TCK) regulates these crimes in separate articles, taking into account different aims and consequences:

• Migrant Smuggling (Turkish Penal Code Article 79)

• Human Trafficking (Turkish Penal Code Article 80)

Both crimes are linked to international conventions. Turkey the United Nations Palermo Convention and its additional protocols. In this context, both criminal sanctions and the protection of victims are paramount.

---

1. Crime of Human Trafficking (Turkish Penal Code Article 80)

a) Elements of the Crime

• Elements of the motive: Threat, coercion, deception, fraud, abuse of power, exploitation of helplessness.

• Purpose element: Sexual abuse, forced labor, organ trafficking, prostitution, enslavement.

• Victims: Typically vulnerable women, children, and refugees.

b) Penalties

• 8–12 years imprisonment + up to 10,000 days' worth of fines

• If there are child victims, consent is irrelevant.

• The penalty is increased if the crime is committed in an organized manner.

📌 Supreme Court 18th Criminal Chamber, Case No. 2020/6142 E., Decision No. 2020/8410 K.
The confiscation of passports from foreign women and forcing them into prostitution has been deemed human trafficking.

---

2. The Crime of Smuggling Migrants (Turkish Penal Code Article 79)

a) Elements of the Crime

• Perpetrator: A person who facilitates the passage of migrants across the border for financial gain.

• Action: To enable entry into or exit from Turkey, or to allow stay in the country.

• Purpose: Usually for commercial gain.

b) Penalties

• 3–8 years imprisonment + up to 10,000 days' worth of fines

• The fact that the crime was committed in an organized mannerand that the victim's life was endangered increases the penalty.

📌 Supreme Court 7th Criminal Chamber, Case No. 2019/3678 E., Decision No. 2019/4712 K.
The actions of the defendants who transported migrants across the Aegean Sea by boat were considered migrant smuggling, but it was not classified as human trafficking because no element of exploitation was found.

---

3. Key Differences Between the Two Crimes

📌 Supreme Court 9th Criminal Chamber, Case No. 2018/6734 E., Decision No. 2019/1120 K.
The defendants' act of bringing Syrian migrants in with promises of work and then employing them like slaves has been deemed human trafficking.

---

4. Investigation and Trial Process

• Competent Court: High Criminal Courts

• Investigation: Conducted by the Public Prosecutor, usually involving international judicial cooperation

• Evidence includes: phone recordings, passport records, witness statements, victim testimonies, and bank transactions.

• Statute of limitations: According to Article 66 of the Turkish Penal Code , a 15-year statute of limitations applies to these crimes

---

5. Victims' Rights and Remedies

a) Asylum and Residence Permit

Victims can apply for international protection by contacting the Directorate of Migration Management

b) Rights to Shelter and Protection

In Turkey, there are special shelters and rehabilitation centers for victims of human trafficking .

c) Legal Aid and the Right to Legal Representation

Under the Code of Criminal Procedure, victims are assigned a lawyer free of charge.

d) Compensation Claims

Victims can also claim financial and moral damages from the perpetrator

📌 Supreme Court Grand Chamber, Case No. 2017/184 E., Decision No. 2017/451 K.
The claim for moral damages by a victim of human trafficking has been accepted.

---

6. International Law Dimension

• Palermo Convention (2000): Imposes an obligation on states to cooperate in preventing human trafficking and migrant smuggling.

• Council of Europe Convention against Trafficking in Persons (2005): Grants victims special protection rights.

• EU Directives: These directives impose obligations on member states to identify and support victims of human trafficking.

---

7. The Role of the Lawyer

From the Defendant's Perspective

• To argue that the elements of the crime have not been met,

• Arguing that the evidence was obtained illegally,

• Requesting that it be considered an administrative violation rather than migrant smuggling

From the Victim's Perspective

• Filing compensation lawsuits,

• To initiate protection and asylum procedures,

• Utilizing international avenues for protection (UN, ECHR).

---

Conclusion

Human trafficking and migrant smuggling are serious crimes regulated separately under Turkish law. Supreme Court rulings are important in defining these boundaries in practice. Victims to shelter, legal representation, residence permits, and compensation . For lawyers, developing multifaceted legal strategies in these crimes is necessary, both for defense and for representing victims.