Young Athletes and Transfers
Introduction: The Importance of Legal Protection for Young Athletes
For sports clubs, investing in infrastructure is a fundamental way to create sustainable success and economic value. However, the transfer, contract signing, and transition to professional life of athletes under the age of 18 are subject to very strict legal rules. The protection of children, their personal development, educational rights, and family integrity take precedence over the commercial dynamics of sports law. Therefore, national law, FIFA regulations, and children's rights principles must be meticulously applied in the transfer processes of young athletes.
In Türkiye, the Turkish Civil Code, the Turkish Code of Obligations, the Convention on the Rights of the Child, the Turkish Football Federation (TFF) and its regulations; and internationally, the FIFA Transfer Regulations (FIFA RSTP) form a multi-layered system protecting young athletes.
1. Legal Status of Athletes Under 18
A. Status of Child and Minor Athletes
An athlete under the age of 18 does not have full legal capacity. Therefore:
-
He cannot sign the contract
-
They cannot enter into wage and bonus agreements
-
Professional transfer agreements may be deemed void.
These athletes can only take legal action with the permission of their parent or guardian
B. Contracts Made Without Parental Consent
Contracts without parental consent:
-
It may be completely void,
-
The club may incur liability for damages
-
It may be subject to a disciplinary investigation.
2. Parental Consent and Legal Formal Requirements
Written parental consent is required for all contracts to be made with young athletes
-
Both the athlete and the parent will sign
-
Notarization will be obtained if necessary
-
A balance will be ensured between education and sports
-
The best interests of the child will be considered.
This permission covers not only the athlete's participation in the club, but also sponsorship deals, advertising shoots, and training camps.
3. The Nature of Young Athlete Contracts: Distinction Between Amateur and Professional
A. Amateur Contracts
This is usually done for junior athletes:
-
Does not include fees (excluding expenses),
-
It is for educational and developmental purposes
-
The timeframe can be fixed, but it shouldn't be oppressive.
B. Professional Contracts
To sign a professional contract in Türkiye:
-
at least 15 years old.
-
Obtaining parental permission,
-
Approval from the TFF (Turkish Football Federation)
is required.
Professional contracts cannot be signed with athletes under the age of 15.
4. Transfer Processes: National and International Rules
A. National Transfers
According to TFF regulations:
-
For athletes under 18, transfers are only possible with parental consent
-
Clubs have a responsibility to train and develop young athletes
-
A breeding allowance is applied.
B. International Transfers: FIFA's Ban on Players Under 18
According to FIFA RSTP:
International transfers of athletes under the age of 18 are generally prohibited.
Exceptions:
-
The family moving to another country for non-sporting reasons,
-
Transfers within the EU/EEA for children aged 16–18,
-
Athletes residing in border regions (50 km rule),
-
Refugee or unaccompanied child status.
This regulation was introduced to protect children from the illegal drug trafficking market.
5. Training Compensation and Club Rights
When young athletes turn professional, clubs can claim training compensation . The calculation involves:
-
The athlete's age,
-
The club's category,
-
Years of education
are taken into account.
Training compensation:
-
It protects the club's investment
-
It prevents pressure from being put on athletes at a young age
-
It provides stability in the transfer market.
CAS rulings emphasize that compensation must be “reasonable and proportionate”.
6. The Right to Education and the Responsibility of Sports Clubs
The most important responsibility of clubs in the transfer of young athletes is to protect their right to education.
Clubs:
-
School attendance must be ensured for the athlete
-
A balance should be struck between educational programs and sports programs
-
It does not implement demanding or training-exclusionary training programs,
-
It supports psychological and social development.
If this obligation is breached, the club faces serious legal risks.
7. Protection of Personal Data of Young Athletes
Regarding young athletes:
-
Health data,
-
Performance records,
-
Physical measurements,
-
Academic information
is classified data.
Clubs are subject to the Personal Data Protection Law (KVKK):
-
Obtaining explicit consent,
-
Storing data securely,
-
not share it with third parties
.
8. Contract Invalidity and Compensation Claims
Reasons for invalidation:
-
Lack of parental consent,
-
Violation of the athlete's right to education,
-
Excessive duration and penalty clauses,
-
The professional requirements are not appropriate for the age.
In this situation:
-
The athlete can have the club ordered to pay compensation
-
The athlete can be released,
-
The club is subject to a disciplinary investigation.
9. Responsibility of Managers and Third Parties
Agents who want to sign contracts with athletes under the age of 18:
-
Complying with FIFA Agent Regulations,
-
to maintain a balance in the development of the school, family, and athlete
.
Secret transfer agreements involving underage athletes result in severe disciplinary penalties.
Conclusion: A safe and legally compliant transfer system is essential for young athletes
Protecting athletes under the age of 18 is a fundamental principle in sports law. Therefore:
-
Transactions made without parental consent are invalid
-
International transfers are prohibited except in exceptional circumstances
-
The right to education takes precedence over all economic concerns
-
Training compensation protects investment in young athletes
-
Clubs and managers must comply with children's rights.
Ensuring the healthy development of young athletes is essential, both for the ethical values of sports and for the functioning of the legal system.
About Post Author
