Vehicle Damage and Loss of Value: Consumer Arbitration Board, Arbitration and Court Processes
How to Claim Vehicle Depreciation through the Consumer Arbitration Board? Insurance Arbitration and Court Procedures
One of the most frequently asked questions by vehicle owners involved in traffic accidents is about "vehicle damage depreciation" and how this loss can be compensated. In many cases, only the repair cost is paid, and the decrease in the vehicle's resale value is often either not claimed at all or claimed insufficiently.
1. What is Vehicle Damage Depreciation?
When a vehicle is involved in a traffic accident , even if the visible damage is repaired, it is still considered a "damaged vehicle." It appears as a damaged vehicle in Tramer (SBM) records, and expert reports show markings under the "paint/replacement" section. Therefore, even after repairs , a difference arises between the vehicle's market value before and after the accident . This difference is referred to in practice as "vehicle depreciation . "
Vehicle damage depreciation is the decrease in value of a vehicle in the used car market after it has been repaired following an accident, due to its damage history.
This damage is often financial loss that must be covered by the at-fault driver and the insurance company that issued their mandatory motor insurance policy
2. Legal Basis for Diminution in Value
Vehicle depreciation "material damage" . The main legal basis is as follows:
-
Articles 49 and subsequent articles of the Turkish Code of Obligations (TBK)
regulate tort liability. The obligation of a negligent driver to compensate for the damage caused is based on these provisions. Decrease in the value of the vehicle is also included within the scope of this damage. -
The Highway Traffic Law (KTK) and Compulsory Financial Liability Insurance (ZMMS)
damages caused by negligent drivers to the property of third parties are covered by traffic insurance . Vehicle damage and subsequent depreciation in value have also been considered within the scope of compulsory traffic insurance according to Supreme Court precedents. -
Consumer Law Aspect:
If the vehicle owner is a consumer, the insurance company is a service provider. In this case, Law No. 6502 on the Protection of Consumers comes into play, the Consumer Arbitration Board / Consumer Court .
In conclusion, the negligent driver and their insurance company are liable for the depreciation in vehicle value when the appropriate conditions arise
3. How is Vehicle Depreciation Calculated?
Calculating the depreciation in value is a technical process and is usually an expert report . The criteria considered are:
-
Vehicle make, model and year of manufacture
-
Kilometers
-
Nature of the damaged parts (support part, chassis, pillar, hood, door, etc.)
-
Whether the parts were replaced or painted
-
Did the vehicle have any other damage prior to the accident?
-
The intended use of the vehicle (private – commercial)
In the insurance sector, there are formulas and various actuarial calculation methods used by the SBM (Insurance Information and Supervision Center) . However, the key point that consumers need to know is:
Depreciation is not “just” the cost of the repair; it refers to the decrease in the vehicle's resale value.
Therefore, rejecting a claim for depreciation simply on the grounds that "parts were replaced and the vehicle was restored to its original condition" is incorrect. Court decisions are based on expert reports prepared with accurate data when determining compensation for depreciation
4. Which Vehicles Can Claim Depreciation?
In practice, automatic depreciation calculations are not performed for every file. Some files have these depreciation values;
-
The vehicle is very old
-
The mileage is very high
-
There are numerous previous records of significant damage
Therefore, no significant loss in value has occurred .
In general, demand for depreciation is stronger in the following situations:
-
If the vehicle is a relatively new model and the mileage is reasonable,
-
If visible and significant damage has occurred in the accident ,
-
painted/replaced parts is high,
-
If the vehicle was previously undamaged or had minor damage.
At this point, authorized service and expert reports important. The expert report includes information such as which parts were replaced, which parts were repainted, the vehicle's mileage, and its market value at the time of the damage. These documents must be included in the file when applying to the Consumer Arbitration Board or the Insurance Arbitration Commission.
5. Distinction Between Consumer Status and Commercial Vehicle
5.1. Who is the Consumer?
According to Law No. 6502, a consumer is a natural person acting for non-commercial or non-professional purposes.
Therefore,who buys and uses a vehicle for their own personal needs is generally a consumer.
-
an intermediary for the commercial activity of their business is not considered a "consumer".
5.2. Distinction Between Commercial and Private Vehicles
-
Taxis, minibuses, trucks, vans, fleet vehicles, logistics vehicles, etc., are often considered commercial vehicles . In these cases , the Consumer Arbitration Board may not have jurisdiction; the matter will be referred directly to the Commercial Court of First Instance or the Insurance Arbitration Commission .
- For vehicles intended for personal use , such as private cars or family vehicles , the vehicle owner is considered a consumer ; in this case, the Consumer Arbitration Board and the Consumer Court can be used.
6. Application to the Consumer Arbitration Board for Vehicle Depreciation
Regarding vehicle depreciation, the Consumer Arbitration Board offers a highly practical and cost-effective solution when the vehicle owner is considered a consumer.
6.1. Authorized Consumer Arbitration Board
Generally
-
The Consumer Arbitration Board in the consumer's place of residence or
-
Consumer Arbitration Board in the place where the consumer transaction took place
They are authorized. In disputes regarding diminished value, it is generally preferred to apply to the arbitration board located in the consumer's place of residence.
6.2. Monetary Limits
There are monetary limits for applications to Consumer Arbitration Boards, determined annually by the Ministry of Trade .
-
For disputes below a certain amount, an arbitration panel will be formed
-
For disputes exceeding these amounts, the Consumer Court (or the Commercial/Civil Court of First Instance if the party does not have consumer status) has jurisdiction.
Since these limits are updated annually, it is essential to check the limits in the most current circular for each specific case .
6.3. Application Procedure
Application to the Consumer Arbitration Board:
-
online via e-Government or
-
By written petition, either in person or by mail
It can be done.
7. Documents Required for Application
When applying to the Consumer Arbitration Board for vehicle damage and depreciation claims , the following documents are generally required to ensure that as complete and organized documentation as possible is submitted:
-
Accident report (prepared by the police or the drivers)
-
Photographs (showing the extent of the damage)
-
Repair invoices, service receipts
-
Expert report (damage assessment and repair information)
-
Photocopy of the vehicle registration certificate
-
Insurance policies (both for the injured party and the at-fault party)
-
with the insurance company , and the responses given.
-
Any incomplete or rejected payment receipts issued by the insurance company.
These documents help the arbitration panel to accurately assess fault , the amount of damages , and the insurance company's liability
8. What should a Consumer Arbitration Board Application Form look like?
The petition should specifically include the following points:
-
Party Information
-
Identity and contact information of the applicant consumer
-
Information about the insurance company (and the driver at fault, if applicable) as the opposing party.
-
-
Summary of the Event
-
Date, location, and parties involved in the accident
-
Fault distribution (according to the accident report)
-
Vehicle damage status (which parts were replaced, which were repainted)
-
-
Legal Reasons
-
Brief reference to the KTK, TBK, ZMMS general terms and conditions and consumer legislation
-
It should be emphasized that vehicle depreciation is considered "material damage" and is covered by mandatory traffic insurance
-
-
Loss Calculation
-
If available, the amount of depreciation stated in the expert/appraiser report
-
Explanation regarding the declared amount of depreciation and the calculation method
-
-
Requests
-
The specified amount of compensation for depreciation,
-
Collection from the insurance company, including interest.
-
If necessary, a request for other expenses related to the application (e.g., appraisal fee) can be made
-
9. What is the Insurance Arbitration Commission?
Insurance arbitration, established under the Insurance Law No. 5684 , is a special judicial method aimed at resolving disputes arising from insurance contracts more quickly and at a relatively lower cost than going to court
9.1. Conditions for Applying for Insurance Arbitration
To apply to the Insurance Arbitration Commission:
-
First, you need to apply to the insurance company in writing.
-
the insurance company gives a negative response within 15 days or does not respond at all,
-
The dispute must be eligible for arbitration and the insurance company must be a member of the arbitration panel.
This is necessary. A significant number of insurance companies are members of the arbitration panel; however, this should definitely against the Commission's current list .
9.2. Advantages of Applying for Arbitration
-
It yields results in a relatively short time.
-
According to the court, there is a more practical procedure involved.
-
Decisions within certain monetary limits are final; for higher amounts, limited legal remedies such as appeals/reviews are available.
-
It can offer a more effective solution, especially compared to courts that are already under a heavy workload
9.3. Comparison of Arbitration Panels, Arbitration, and Courts
The choice of arbitration route in a vehicle depreciation dispute whether the vehicle owner is a consumer or not, the amount of the dispute, the insurance company's membership in the arbitration panel, and your preference for speed and cost .
10. In which situations is the Consumer Arbitration Board used, and in which situations is arbitration used?
10.1. Example Scenario 1 – Private Vehicle, Has Consumer Status
The vehicle owner is a consumer and the vehicle is for private use.
The at-fault party's traffic insurance company either paid less than the full amount or no amount at all for the depreciation in value.
The amount of the dispute is below the monetary limit set by the Consumer Arbitration Board for that year .
In this situation;
-
Applying to the Consumer Arbitration Board is the most practical way.
-
also to the Insurance Arbitration Commission , but both arbitration and court proceedings cannot be pursued simultaneously for the same dispute.
10.2. Example Scenario 2 – High Dispute Amount
The consumer vehicle owner,
If the amount of depreciation, including interest and expenses, exceeds the arbitration board's limits,
In this case , the Consumer Court, not the Consumer Arbitration Board, is responsible.
Nevertheless, the Insurance Arbitration Commissionmay be strategically preferred due to the possibility of a quick resolution.
10.3. Example Scenario 3 – Commercial Vehicle
The vehicle is used for commercial purposes (taxi, truck, etc.).
The vehicle owner is a trader.
In this situation, since the party generally does not have consumer status, the Consumer Arbitration Board route is closed.
Options:
-
directly in the Commercial Court of First Instance ,
-
if the conditions are met .
11. Statute of Limitations and Time Limits
The statute of limitations for vehicle depreciation claims is generally to compensation claims arising from traffic accidents .
Generally:
-
The short statute of limitations period is 2 years (starting from the date of learning about the damage and the person liable for compensation).
-
In any case, a long statute of limitations of 10 years.
However, longer statutes of limitations may apply if the accident also constitutes a crime .
In consumer disputes, the statute of limitations provisions in consumer law must also be taken into account.
Therefore, in practice, the shortest possible time from the date of the incident:
-
Written application and warning to the negligent driver and insurance company ,
-
If no resolution is reached, recourse can be sought through the Consumer Arbitration Board, arbitration, or court.
This is extremely important to avoid losing your rights.
12. Interest and Payment Terms
When claiming compensation for vehicle depreciation, not only the principal amount but also the interest to be claimed must be clearly stated. Interest can be claimed from the date of the written application or notice to the insurance company, or from the date of the lawsuit/application.
At this point, the type of interest (legal interest, advance interest, default interest) and the commencement date must be clearly stated in the application.
13. Common Mistakes in Vehicle Depreciation Claims
In vehicle depreciation claims, some typical mistakes made by both consumers and sometimes professionals lead to loss of rights:
-
Application with Missing Documents
-
Applications made without an accident report, expert report, invoice, and photographs have weak probative value.
-
-
Applying to the Wrong Authority
-
Application to the Consumer Arbitration Board for commercial vehicles,
-
Insisting on arbitration for disputes exceeding the monetary limit are mistakes that lead to a waste of time.
-
-
To mistake only the cost of damage for actual loss
-
Forgetting to claim compensation for depreciation after paying the repair bill is a significant loss.
-
-
Ignoring the Statute of Limitations
-
Waiting for years and then trying to claim compensation for diminished value may result in an objection based on the statute of limitations.
-
-
Insufficient or Incorrectly Calculated Requests
-
Claiming a depreciation amount significantly below the actual value can lead to losses, as there may be limited opportunities for subsequent increases.
-
For these reasons, " seeking professional assistance," especially in high-stakes and technically complex cases, provides a significant advantage in the legal process.
14. Conclusion: Strategic Use of Consumer Arbitration Boards, Arbitration, and Court Remedies
Vehicle damage loss is an often overlooked loss that has significant economic implications for the vehicle owner. Especially with new and low-mileage vehicles, the depreciation in value after an accident can sometimes even higher than the cost of repairs .
During this process:
-
Consumer Arbitration Board
-
Free of charge,
-
Relatively fast,
-
It is a practical solution designed to benefit the consumer.
-
-
Insurance Arbitration Commission
-
When no result is obtained from the application to the insurance company,
-
Particularly in technical disputes specific to insurance law,
-
According to the court, it offers the possibility of achieving results in a shorter period of time.
-
-
Consumer Court / Commercial Court of First Instance
-
In high-stakes and complex disputes,
-
In disputes with insurance companies that are not subject to arbitration,
-
It intervenes to provide a definitive legal solution.
-
When a vehicle depreciation claim is pursued with the right strategy and evidence, it is possible to recover a significant portion of the actual damage suffered by the consumer. Seeking professional assistance in this process will greatly help you obtain compensation for your losses.
About Post Author
