How to Object to Enforcement Proceedings Against a Consumer Promissory Note, What are the Deadlines and Strategies?

1) Introduction

One of the most common problems in consumer transactions is the initiation of enforcement proceedings by creditors on promissory notes (consumer bills of exchange) that have been signed. These notes, particularly those issued by private schools, beauty salons, courses, and sports centers, are often drawn up in violation of Article 4/5 of the Consumer Protection Law. In such cases, it is crucial for the consumer to object at the right time and with the right reasons.

---

2) Appeal Periods

• In enforcement proceedings based on a negotiable instrument: An application must be made to the enforcement court within 5 days of the notification of the payment order (Article 168 of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law).

• In enforcement proceedings through general attachment: An objection must be filed with the enforcement office within 7 days of notification (Article 62 of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law).

• Complaints regarding enforcement proceedings: If there are procedural irregularities, a complaint can generally be filed with the enforcement court within 7 days.

Note: These deadlines are forfeiture periods, and failure to do so eliminates the consumer's right to object.

---

3) Grounds for Appeal and Strategies

A) Consumer Bill Irregularities

• If the promissory note is not made out to a specific person (if it is issued to order),

• If a single promissory note has been issued for installment payments,

• If a promissory note is signed blank and then filled in later,
  this is contrary to the Turkish Consumer Protection Law. Any bill of exchange proceedings initiated based on such a note may be cancelled.

B) Objection to Signature

• If the signature on the promissory note does not belong to the debtor, the defense "This signature is not mine" must be presented.

• An expert examination is requested to prove the claim.

C) Lack of Compliance and Defective Service

• The service may not have been used at all or may have been used only partially.

• With the logic of "pro-rata refund," it could be argued that the remaining amount would not be charged after deducting the usage period.

• Defective service (e.g., harmful consequences documented by a medical report) constitutes a strong basis for objection.

D) Objection to Jurisdiction

• There is a special jurisdiction rule in favor of the consumer: lawsuits can also be filed in the consumer's place of residence.

• The clause in the undertaking stating "only the courts at the institution's headquarters have jurisdiction" is invalid.

---

4) Form and Authority for Appeal

• In exchange transaction enforcement proceedings: An application must be submitted to the enforcement court within 5 days.

• In general enforcement proceedings: Written or oral objections can be made to the enforcement office within 7 days.

• The appeal must include:

  • The promissory note originated from a consumer transaction,

  • Violations of Article 4/5 of the Turkish Consumer Protection Law,

  • Unfair conditions,

  • Unused services
    should be clearly indicated.

---

5) Anonymous Fictional Event

Case:
"Person M." enrolled their child in "A. College," and a promissory note was signed for an annual fee of 120,000 TL. The note included a clause stating "no refund upon cancellation." The family moved to a different city, but the child did not continue attending the school. The school initiated enforcement proceedings for the promissory note.

Solution:

• M. Person must object to the payment order with the enforcement court within 5 days.

• In his objection;

  • The promissory note is contrary to the Turkish Consumer Protection Law (single promissory note + payable to order)

  • I believe the clause "no refunds" is an unfair condition

  • no fee can be charged for unused time
    .

• The court may dismiss the proceedings; the school will then have to file a lawsuit according to general provisions.

---

6) Strategic Recommendations

• Keep these documents: contracts, letters of commitment, promissory notes, brochures, payment receipts.

• Pay attention to the deadlines: Don't miss the 5-day period.

• Make multiple objections: Issues such as signature, authorization, lack of consideration, and irregularities in the consumer promissory note can be raised in the same petition.

• Request a hearing: Allow the judge to make an in-person assessment.

• Include evidence: reports showing defective service, documents for unused periods.

---

7) Short Petition Framework

… To the Enforcement Law Court
Debtor (Consumer): A. Person (anonymous)
Creditor: A. College (anonymous)
Subject: Objection to bill of exchange payment order and cancellation of enforcement proceedings

Explanations:

• The promissory note in question was issued as a single, payable-to-order note, in violation of Article 4/5 of the Turkish Consumer Protection Law.

• Since the promissory note was obtained as part of a consumer transaction, it is not suitable for bill of exchange enforcement proceedings in its current form.

• The "no refund" clause in the contract is an unfair term under Article 5 of the Turkish Consumer Protection Law.

• My client did not receive the service and is therefore not indebted.

Conclusion: I request that the foreign exchange proceedings be cancelled.

---

8) Conclusion

The most important weapon in enforcement proceedings against consumer promissory notes is a timely and properly justified objection. Articles 4/5 and 5 of the Consumer Protection Law provide significant protection for consumers. If rules such as registered promissory notes, separate notes per installment, and the prohibition of unfair terms are violated, the enforcement proceedings may be cancelled.